Wellington Scoop

Five categories of covid abuse

prof baker

by Hamish MacLean
Covid-19 experts are not immune to increasingly vitriolic attacks dished out to scientists commenting on New Zealand’s pandemic response. Among a litany of attacks that Wellington-based epidemiologist Prof Michael Baker has endured over the course of the pandemic, at the start of this week a caller told him he had “a target on his back”.

Prof Baker said he kept the caller on the line for about 20 minutes and asked him what that meant “in real terms”.

The caller was an anti-vaxxer who was accusing Prof Baker of propaganda on behalf of pharmaceutical companies, telling him vaccines were dangerous, especially so for children.

The caller had half-baked information gleaned from various sources that did not really make sense, Prof Baker said.

“He had these slogans he was throwing at me, but when I asked him what he meant he didn’t really have any answers.”

This week it was revealed University of Auckland professors Shaun Hendy and Siouxsie Wiles have argued to the Employment Relations Authority their employer was not doing enough to protect them as they shared their expertise with the public.

But Prof Baker said he had not raised any concerns for his safety with his employer, the University of Otago. If anyone made a threat where he felt he or his family was unsafe he would not hesitate to involve the police.

The Wellington-based scientist received the occasional phone call where a caller delivered a stream of abuse and hung up, but Prof Baker said he was most likely to receive abuse in the form of emails, averaging a few attacks by email every day.

As an exercise, Prof Baker began classifying the forms of abuse he received into “five categories of insult”, he said.

There were the incoherent streams of abuse, which were easily dealt with, he said.

Some people had major grievances but did not know where to go, and contacted him to vent and, in some extremely sad cases, he would reply and express sorrow and sympathy.

There were anti-vax propagandists whose positions were not based in facts, which he ignored.

There were those with ideological stances who disapproved of the government’s overall strategy, who at times delved into conspiracy theories.

Finally, the group he found the hardest to deal with came as personal attacks from a small stream of people who persistently contacted him, and tried to undermine his ability to comment.

“Talking about how you look, or how you appear – they’re obviously making quite a concerted effort to look at where you might feel a bit vulnerable.”

The attacks had never made him question his role of speaking publicly about the pandemic response, he said.

University of Otago evolutionary virologist Dr Jemma Geoghegan said she, too, had not raised any concerns with her employer. She said “no” to about 90 percent of media requests because the issues were not related to her field of expertise. In limiting her media exposure, she had limited the number of people who wanted to harass her about her expertise, Dr Geoghegan said.

“I don’t generally speak about vaccines, so [that] abuse isn’t aimed at me,” the Dunedin scientist said. However, she had published on Covid-19 origins and people had “weirdly strong views about that”.

The issues dealt with by her Auckland counterparts were not surprising though and she had sympathy for them.

“This is happening all around the world,” Dr Geoghegan said. “I’ve got international collaborators that … I think their mental health has suffered. Before Covid, or at the start of Covid, they were really prominent on Twitter and stuff like that, and now they’ve had to delete their accounts because of the amount of abuse they’ve got.”

This report was earlier published by RNZ after first appearing in the Otago Daily Times

Read also:
Siouxsie Wiles on almost two years of abuse and harassment


  1. J Chris Horne, 8. January 2022, 21:00

    Prof Michael Baker, Dr Jemma Geohegan, Prof. Shaun Hendy and Prof. Siouxsie Wiles and many other skilled individuals do vital work keeping Kiwis informed about Covid-19 Delta and Omicron variants, advising us about the risks these diseases pose to our health and how to minimise those risks. Meanwhile the thousands of staff at MIQ facilities, testing laboratories, vaccination clinics, general practitioners and hospital nursing staff work long hours diligently helping to keep us all safe.

    Heartfelt thanks are due to everyone of them!

  2. Claire, 9. January 2022, 10:42

    I would also like to thank all people who have had a role at the forefront of guiding NZ through the pandemic. Including Jacinda Ardern, Ashley Bloomfield, Chris Hipkins and all the scientific experts mentioned above.
    To the detractors: it’s hard when you hear things about science you don’t understand, but this is the time to listen to it and follow. Old wives’ tales and anecdotes are false and rely on your lack of knowledge to convince.

  3. Kara, 10. January 2022, 15:15

    I also want to thank those who have shared their knowledge and expertise. It is sad when a sector of our society use their lack of understanding of science as a weapon against our scientists and central government personnel who only want to keep us healthy.

  4. Geoff, 16. January 2022, 21:00

    It goes both ways, i’ve seen vitriol against anti-vaxers. Be nice if others would respect others beliefs and views.

  5. Dave B, 21. January 2022, 21:32

    I hardly think the scientists and experts who are on the receiving end of anti-vaxer vitriol are dishing it back in return. Vitriol comes from people who choose rudeness over civility, whichever side of the argument they may be on.


Write a comment: